Prospect SP Priority Lists by system (turn sideways on mobile)

We will start with a blank slate in 2025, adding arms (yet to make MLB debut) as we watch their full-sea­son work, pair­ing previous/other knowl­edge with said looks. “Pri­or­i­ty” here means whose career I’d be will­ing to bet (at the moment) yields the most MLB start­ing pitch­ing suc­cess, list­ed most opti­mistic (top) to most pes­simistic (bot­tom). There will be plen­ty of names here not worth a dynasty play. At least at the moment, and how sil­ly it may be. Feel free to jump into the Dis­cord and ask any ques­tions you have. ** (RP?) means I have more ques­tions than most over the play­er hav­ing the horses/durability/size and/or abil­i­ty to exe­cute their pitch­es at a req­ui­site MLB SP qual­i­ty. Age and lev­el may not be up to date as they are the age and lev­el when entered on the list. I will update those spo­rad­i­cal­ly.

Ath­let­icsAstrosMarinersAngelsRangers
Gage JumpL22AAMiguel Ullo­la (RP?)R22AAARyan SloanR19AGeorge Klassen (RP?)R23AADavid Davalil­loR22A+
Luis MoralesR22AAAJack­son NezuhR23AAJur­range­lo Cjin­t­jeS21A+Austin Gor­donR21A+Mitch BrattL21AA
Steven Echavar­riaR19A+Jose FleuryR23AAWal­ter FordR20AKeythel Key (RP?)R21A+Ryan Lobus (RP?)R24AA
Kade Mor­risR22AAAnder­son Brito (RP?)R20A+Chris­t­ian Lit­tleR21A+Samy Natu­ra (RP?)L25AALean­dro LopezR22A+
Jack PerkinsR25AAACar­los Espinosa (RP?)R23A+
Will John­ston (RP?)L23AARaimy RodriguezR19AJorge MarchecoR22A+Jose Gon­za­lezR23A+
Mason Bar­nettR24AAARyan CostieuR24AABrooks FowlerR22A
Wei-En LinL19AD.J. McCar­ty (RP?)R22A+
Chen Zhong Ao ZhuangR24AAKam­dyn Per­ryR19A
Sam StuhrR22A
Car­los Duran (RP?)R23AAA
James Gon­za­lezL24AA
Tzu-Chen ShaR21A
Don­ny Tro­co­nisR19A
Jef­fer­son JeanR20A
Rock­iesPadresGiantsDia­mond­backsDodgers
Gabriel Hugh­esR23AAHen­ry BaezR22AACar­son Whisen­huntL24AAADaniel EagenR22A+Aiden Foeller (RP?)R23A
Blake AdamsR24AABraden NettR22AACar­son Sey­mour (RP?)R26AAASpencer Giest­ingL23AAChris­t­ian Zazue­taR20A
Brody Brecht (RP?)R23AEric YostR22A+Trevor McDon­ald (RP?)R24AAAJose Cabr­eraR22AASean Linan (RP?)R20AAA
Kon­nor EatonL22A+Miguel MendezR22A+Greg FaroneL23ADyl­sn RayR24AAJerming Rosario (RP?)R22AA
Labar­ron John­sonR22ABryan Balz­erR20AJuan Mer­cedesR24AAARoman Ange­loR24AASter­ling Pat­ickL19A
Vic­tor Jau­rez (RP?)R21AALuis Gui­ter­rezL21AJohn WestR23A+
Mike Pros­eckyR24A+Dan­ny Lar­ron­doR22A
Ricar­do YanR22A+
Junior SanchezR19A
Brew­ersCubsPiratesCar­di­nalsReds
Jacob Misiorows­ki (RP?)R23AAARyan Gal­lagherR22A+Bub­ba Chan­dlerR22AAAQuinn Math­ewsL24AAAChase BurnsR22AA
Tyson HardinR23A+Jax­on Wig­ginsR23A+Hunter Bar­coR24AAAIxan Hen­der­sonL23AAAdam Ser­winos­kiL20A+
Bish­op Let­sonR20A+Grant KippR25AAThomas Har­ring­tonR23AAATekoah Roby (RP?)R23AAJose Mon­teroR21A+
Tate Kuehn­er (RP?)L24AAWill SandersR23AAAlessan­dro ERcolani (RP?)R21AASem Rob­berse (FS IL)R23AAAHunter Parks (RP?)R24AA
K.C. HuntR24AATyler Schlaf­ferR24A+Chen-Wei LinR23A+
Alexan­der Cornielle (RP?)R23AAJuan SalasR22A+
Chan­dler WelchR22A+Nel­fry Ynfante (RP?)R22A
Manuel RodriguezR19A+Jason Sava­cool (RP?)R22A
Melvin Her­nan­dezR18ALeonel Sequera (RP?)R19A
Brandt Thomp­sonR22A
Braden DavisL22A
White SoxTwinsTigersGuardiansRoy­als
Hagen SmithL21AACharlee SotoR19A+Jake MillerL23AABray­lon DoughtyR19ADrew BeamR22A+
Noah SchultzL21AAAndrew Mor­risR23AAAOwen HallR19AWill DionL25AAALuin­der Avi­laR23AAA
Grant Tay­lor (RP?)R22AADasan HillL19AJaden HammR22AAAaron Dav­en­portR24AABen Kudr­naR22AA
Tyler SchweitzerL24AAADylan Ques­tadR20AJoseph Mon­tal­voR23AARafe SchlesingerL22AFelix ArrondeR22A+
Shane Panzi­niR23AA
Yunior MarteR21A
Riley Gowens (RP?)R25AAMar­co RayaR22AAARayn­er Castil­loR20A+Matt Wilkin­sonL22A+Frank Mozzi­ca­toL21A+
Shane Mur­phyL24AA
Wikel­man Gon­za­lezR23AACole Peschl (RP?)R22AHay­den MintonR24AJack­son HumphriesL20A+Hunter OwenL23AA
Gabriel ReyesL21AJogly Gar­cia (RP?)R21AHunter Pat­te­sonL25A+
Lucas ElissaltR20ATom­my MaceR26AADavid ShieldsL18A
Josh HanselR23A
RaysOri­olesYan­keesRed SoxBlue Jays
San­ti­a­go SuarezR20A+Nestor Ger­manR23AACar­los LagrangeR21AAPay­ton TolleL22A+Trey Yesav­ageR21A+
Ian Sey­mourL26AAABrax­ton BraggR24AABen HessR22A+Yor­dan­ny Mon­e­groR22AAKhal StephenR22A+
T.J. NicholsR22A+Cam West­on (RP?)R24AAABryce Cun­ning­hamR22A+Bran­don ClarkeL22A+Ryan Jen­nings (RP)R25AAA
Jose Urbina R19ATrey Gib­sonR23A+Trent Sell­ersR25AACon­nel­ly Ear­lyL23AAJuaron Watts-Brown (RP?)R23AA
Ben Peo­plesR24AAAMichael For­rettR21A+Cam Schlit­tlerR24AAHay­den Mullins (RP?)L24AAMichael Dominguez (RP?)R24AA
Gary Gill HillR20A+Blake Mon­eyR23A+Elmer Rodriguez-CruzR21A+Eduar­do Rivera (RP?)L21AGage Stan­i­fer (RP?)R21A+
J.J. GossR24AAAlex PhamR25AAGrif­fin Her­ringL22ATyler Uber­s­tineR25AAALazaro Estra­daR26AAA
Joe Rock (RP?)L24AAARiley Coop­erL23A+Josh GroszR22A+Juan Valera (RP?)R19A+Col­by Hol­combeR22A
Brody Hop­kins (RP?)R23AATy Weath­er­lyR24A+Tyrone Yulie (RP)R23A+Jojo Ingras­sia (RP?)L22A+Gilber­to BatistaR20A
Ty John­son (RP?)R23AAKeel­er Morfe (RP?)R18ADan­ny FlattR20AJedix­son PaezR21A+C.J. Van EykR26AAA
Logan Work­manR26AAAAustin CatesR22A
Trevor Har­ri­sonR19AFer­nan­do PerezR21A+
Owen WildR22AADev­ereaux Har­ri­sonR24AA
Hay­den Snel­sire (RP?)R24A+Chris McEl­vain (RP?)R24A
Jack­son Baumeis­terR22AARafael SanchezR25AA
Edi­in­son Batista (RP)R23A+
MetsBravesMar­linsPhilliesNation­als
Bran­don SproatR24AAADidi­er FuentesR19AARob­by SnellingR21AAAndrew PainterR22AAATravis Syko­raR21A
Jon­ah Tong (RP?)R23AAJ.R. RitchieR21AAThomas WhiteL20A+Eiber­son Castel­lano (RP?)R23AAAlex Clem­meyL19A+
Joel DiazR21A+Lucas BraunR23AALiomar Mar­tinezR19ALuke Rus­soR24AAJack­son KentL22A+
Nolan McLean (RP?)R23AAAHer­ick Her­nan­dez (RP?)R21A+Noble Mey­erR20A+Griff McGar­ry (RP?)R25AAJar­lin Susana (RP?)R21AA
Zach Thorn­tonL23AARayven Anto­nioR19AKeyn­er Ben­itezL19ARyan DeggesR22AAndrew AlvarezL25AAA
Felipe De La Cruz (RP?)L24AAAAdam Maier (RP?)R23A+Jacob MillerR21AAReese Dut­tonR24AJake Ben­nettR24A+
Jonathan San­tuc­ciL22A+Drue Hack­en­berg (RP?)R23AAWill Schomberg (RP?)R24A+Luke GabryshR22AYoel Teje­daR21A
Joan­der SuarezR25AARobin­son PinaR26AAASam High­fillR24AAndry Lara (RP?)R22AAA
Jack Wen­ningerR23AAEmmett OlsonL23A+Luke Tukis (RP?)R22AHyun-il ChoiR25AA
Welling­ton Ara­ce­na (RP?)R20ABrayan Men­dozaL21A+Travis StheleR23A+
Rai­mon Gomez (RP?)R23A+Dax Ful­tonL23AA
Frank ElissaltR23ANick BrinkR23A+
Austin Troess­er (RP?)R23A+Eli­azar Dish­mey (RP?)R20A
Matt AllanR24A+Kar­son Mil­brandt (RP?)R21A+
Ike Bux­ton (RP?)R24A+
Luis Pala­ciosL24AA

** Any gaps on the lists don’t mean any­thing except that the for­mat­ting on these tables is clunky, and I haven’t tedious­ly cleaned them up.

Last updat­ed 6/1/25

Back to muddylooks.com home